Serena Hayes, who suffers from night blindness, notices that her boyfriend Oliver has two sides: a reckless playboy and a gentle gentleman. When her lost pen ends up with Lucas Vance, a major client of the company, Serena approaches him to uncover the truth and discovers their hidden arrangement. Oliver uses Serena as a replacement for his long-lost love Taylor, while Lucas is forced to take Oliver’s place to protect the company’s interests. As the reserved Lucas slowly falls for Serena, he struggles to keep his distance. When their secrets are finally exposed, Serena stays calm and asks, “Lucas, should we give us a try?”